I cannot imagine trying to place an eyelash on such a small surface and getting it perfect. Unfortunately, it's those eyelashes that can totally ruin a doll's face in a photograph. If the eyelash is too low, too high, or crooked, it's enough reason to return a head to Customer Care. It's the most disappointing part of doll collecting for me, personally.
Integrity Toys didn't always apply eyelashes to their dolls. They started experimenting with these eyelashes in 2005, using them with their Atelier and Exclusive lines. Prior to these lines, all Integrity Toys had naked eyes! Some of these dolls remain in my collection today (although they've been upgraded to taller, articulated bodies).
Recently, my husband came up with a very good idea to help me narrow my focus in collecting. He suggested I take photos of my dolls without any jewelry or clothing. As he pointed out, "You're able to change the bodies; isn't it just the face and hair that is important to you?" So I started taking "mug shots" of my dolls. Even without applied eyelashes, these girls have managed to always make the cut.
The oldest dolls in my collection are from 2004. Three are Veronique Perrin. This is Diamond Dusted Veronique from the 2004 IFDC Convention. She cost $125 and there were 500 in her edition.
Next up is Sheer Goddess. I named this doll Eris. She was my one of my favorite dolls from 2004 and got a great deal of photo time. She cost $100 and was released in an edition size of 1000.
Graphic Language represents mold 2.0 of Adele Makeda. (I don't have a version of mold 1.0 in my collection.) She cost $60 and her edition size was 1000.
The next doll is still one of my favorite Kyori Sato (mold 1.0) dolls. Her name is Glam Slam. She had an edition size of 1200 and cost $60.
Vanessa Perrin (1.0) quickly became a collectors' favorite. Unfortunately, Shock Bon Bon is the doll that helped coin the phrase "wonky eye". Veronica Hage corrected the problem for me. Even with the problem this doll's edition size of 1200 sold out quickly and she is still sought after by many collectors. They can't pick her up for the $60 price tag though.
2005 ushered in another new character. Age of Opulence Isha Kalpana Narayanan ($120/1000 edition size). Again, it is very difficult to match this early Indian skin tone to a tall body. My girl is using the Rare Find Isha body.
In 2006, Integrity Toys introduced a new, taller body for their dolls. The first issue of basic dolls did not have eyelashes. From this group, only Urban Antoinette Adele ($70/1300 edition size) still lives here. I love this doll.
The convention collection from 2006 was also without eyelashes. Sound Advice Veronique (now called Ondine) is my only OOAK doll by Vincent Tripani (Vin).
In addition to the regular FR line, I have two NuFace dolls that were released without eyelashes. One is Paint In Black Colette Duranger. She was a BIC exclusive and I remember thinking that $230 was a lot of money for a gift set (only 800 were made). She was my contestant in the Pink Parlor Next Top Doll contest, so she will always be very special to me.
The other is another NuFace doll that I absolutely adore - Urban Outfitting Nadja Rhymes.
Excluding most of the Monogram line and some earlier NuFace dolls, only the Cult Couture group from 2007 was released without eyelashes.
There are only twelve dolls (eight different characters) without eyelashes living here: 1 Vanessa, 1 Kyori, 1 Natalia, 1 Isha, 2 Adele, and 4 Veronique, 1 Colette, and 1 Nadja. I think they are beautiful. They definitely don't need no stinkin' lashes!
BTW did you notice how many of these dolls show white under their irises? When dolls started showing up with eyelashes, that white started bothering collectors. I think the eyelashes reduced the amount of iris and exaggerated the white. Just a thought ….