I struggled with including this doll in the 12 of 2012. She was one of the Rock Wedding Dolls from the 2011 W Club Membership. Although she was offered at the end of 2011, she wasn't received until this year. I don't list a doll on my "Best of" list that I don't have in hand. As we all know the production doll can look much different than the promo. Since she wasn't on the list last year, I have rationalized including her in 2012.